Figures and Tables
6.4Cobalt-Base Alloys
6.4.0General Comments

The use of cobalt in wrought heat-resistant alloys is usually limited to additions of cobalt to alloys of other bases. Very few of the heat-resistant alloys can be considered as cobalt base, since cobalt is seldom the predominating element. For airframe applications, some workability is usually required; the alloys considered in this section are limited to those available in wrought form.

6.4.0.1Metallurgical Considerations

Composition — The common alloying elements for cobalt are chromium, nickel, carbon, molybdenum, and tungsten. Chromium is added to increase strength and oxidation resistance at very high temperatures; nickel to increase toughness; carbon to increase the hardness and strength, especially when combined with chromium and the other carbide formers, molybdenum and tungsten; molybdenum and tungsten also contribute to solid-solution strengthening.

Vacuum melting is not required for these alloys. For this reason, the cobalt-base alloys are often competitively priced with vacuum-melted nickel-base alloys although the price of cobalt is higher than that of nickel.

Heat Treatment — The cobalt-base alloys are heat treated with conventional equipment and fixtures such as those used with austenitic stainless steels. The use of good heat-treating practices is recommended, although this is not so critical as in the case of the nickel-based alloys.

6.4.0.2Manufacturing Considerations

Forging — Because these alloys are designed to have very high strength at temperatures near the forging range, they require the use of heavy forging equipment. However, the forgeability of these alloys is good over a fairly wide range of temperatures. Hot-cold working is neither required nor recommended for these alloys.

Cold Forming — These alloys, when in the solution-treated condition, have excellent ductility and are readily cold formed. Because of their capacity for work hardening, they require higher forming pressures and frequent anneals.

Machining — These alloys are tough and they work harden rapidly; consequently, heavy-duty vibration-free machine tools, sharp cutting tools (high-speed steel or carbide tipped), and low cutting speeds are required.

Welding — The weldability of the cobalt-base alloys is comparable with that of the austenitic stainless steels. Welding may be accomplished by all commonly used welding processes. Large or complex weldments require stress relief.

Brazing — These alloys can be brazed using the same techniques and precautions applicable to stainless steels and nickel-base alloys. Alloys which contain aluminum or titanium require extremely dry, inert gas atmospheres, very high vacuum or a thin (0.002 to 0.0010 inch thick) nickel plating to prevent surface oxidation. It is also necessary to braze the material in the annealed condition and to keep the stresses low during brazing to avoid embrittlement, especially when brazing with low melting alloys.

6.4.0.3Special Precautions

If the cobalt-base alloys have not been exposed to neutron radiation, no special safety precautions in handling are required. However, neutron irradiation creates a very dangerous radioactive isotope, cobalt 60, which has a half life of about 5.2 years. Special precautions must be employed to protect personnel from the radioactive material.

6.4.1L-605 (Haynes Alloy 25)
6.4.1.0Comments and Properties

L-605, also known as Haynes Alloy 25, is a corrosion and heat-resistant cobalt-base alloy used for moderately stressed parts operating between 1000 and 1900°F. Its applications include gas turbine blades and rotors, combustion chambers, and afterburner parts. L-605 is not hardenable except by cold working and is usually used in the annealed condition. It is available in all the usual mill forms.

L-605 forges moderately well between 1900°F and 2250°F. In the annealed condition, it has excellent formability at room temperature; severely formed parts should be annealed at 2225°F for 7 to 10 minutes. L-605 is difficult to machine. Its toughness and capacity for work hardening necessitate the use of sharp tools and low cutting speeds; high-speed steel or carbide cutting tools are recommended. L-605 can be fusion or resistance welded or brazed; large or complex fusion weldment should be stress relieved at 1300°F for 2 hours. This alloy has excellent oxidation resistance up to 1900°F.

Some material specifications for L-605 are shown in Table 6.4.1.0(a). Room-temperature mechanical and physical properties are shown in Table 6.4.1.0(b). The effect of temperature on physical properties is shown in Figure 6.4.1.0.

Table 6.4.1.0(a). Material Specifications for L-605
SpecificationFormCondition
AMS 5537SheetSolution treated (annealed)
AMS 5759Bar and forgingSolution treated (annealed)
6.4.1.1Solution Treated Condition

Elevated temperature properties for this condition are shown in Figures 6.4.1.1.1 through 6.4.1.1.5. A creep nomograph is shown in Figure 6.4.1.1.7. Stress-rupture requirements at elevated temperatures are specified in material specifications. The appropriate specification should be consulted for detailed requirements.

Table 6.4.1.0(b). Design Mechanical and Physical Properties of L-605
SpecificationAMS 5537AMS 5759
FormSheetPlateBar and forging
ConditionSolution treated
Thickness, in.0.010-0.1870.188-0.375≤1.000
BasisABSS
Mechanical Properties:
Ftu, ksi:
L126131···125
LT130135130···
Fty, ksi:
L5762···45
LT55a6055···
Fcy, ksi:
L4145···42
LT5661······
Fsu, ksi91959188
Fbru, ksi:
(e/D = 1.5)186193186···
(e/D = 2.0)232241232···
Fbry, ksi:
(e/D = 1.5)889688···
(e/D = 2.0)113123113···
e, percent (S-basis):
L·········30
LTb···45···
E, 103 ksi32.6
Ec, 103 ksi32.6
G, 103 ksi12.6
μ0.29
Physical Properties:
ω, lb/in.30.330
C, Btu/(lb)(°F)0.090 (70-212°F)
C, K, and αSee Figure 6.4.1.0
a S-basis. The rounded T99 value: Fty = 56 ksi.
b 30 - ≤0.020; 35 - 0.021 to 0.032; 40 - 0.033 to 0.043; 45 - ≥0.043.
Figure 6.4.1.0Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.1.0. Effect of temperature on the physical properties of L-605.

Open this page of MIL-HDBK-5

Figure 6.4.1.1.1. Effect of temperature on the tensile ultimate strength (Ftu) and the tensile yield strength (Fty) of L-605.

Figure 6.4.1.1.2Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.1.1.2. Effect of temperature on the compressive yield strength (Fcy) and the shear ultimate strength (Fsu) of L-605.

Figure 6.4.1.1.3Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.1.1.3. Effect of temperature on the bearing ultimate strength (Fbru) and the bearing yield strength (Fbry) of L-605 sheet.

Figure 6.4.1.1.4(a)Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.1.1.4(a). Effect of temperature on dynamic moduli (E and Ec) of L-605 sheet.

Figure 6.4.1.1.4(b)Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.1.1.4(b). Effect of temperature on the shear modulus (G) of L-605 sheet.

Figure 6.4.1.1.5Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.1.1.5. Effect of temperature on the elongation (e) of L-605 (>0.020 thickness) sheet.

Figure 6.4.1.1.7Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.1.1.7. Typical creep properties of L-605 sheet.

Correlative Information for Figure 6.4.1.1.7

Equation
Creep Strain, percent:
\[ \varepsilon = \left(3.516\times10^{8}\exp\left(-\frac{56040}{T}\right)\right)\left(\sigma^{0.2791\exp\left(\frac{3943}{T}\right)}\right)\left(t^{0.4172\exp\left(\frac{413.4}{T}\right)}\right) \]a

Temperature (T) = Fahrenheit + 460

a This equation should only be used in the same temperature ranges indicated in the nomograph. Creep strains computed outside these temperature ranges may yield unreasonable values.

Example
Temp., T = 1600°F
Stress, σ = 8 ksi
Time, t = 10 hours
Creep Strain, ε = 0.091

6.4.2HS 188
6.4.2.0Comments and Properties

HS 188 is a corrosion- and heat-resistant cobalt-base alloy used for moderately stressed parts up to 2100°F. The alloy exhibits outstanding oxidation resistance up to 2100°F resulting from the addition of minute amounts of lanthanum to the alloy system. The alloy exhibits excellent post-aged ductility after prolonged heating of 1000 hours at temperatures up to 1600°F inclusive.

HS 188 is not hardenable except by cold working and is used in the solution-treated condition. The alloy can be forged and welded. Welding can be accomplished by both manual and automatic welding methods including electron beam, gas tungsten air, and resistance welding. Like other cobalt base alloys, machining is difficult necessitating the use of sharp tools and low cutting speeds; high speed steel or carbide cutting tools are recommended. Gas turbine applications include transition ducts, combustion cans, spray bars, flame--holders, and liners.

Material specifications for HS 188 are presented in Table 6.4.2.0(a). Room-temperature mechanical and physical properties are shown in Table 6.4.2.0(b). The effect of temperature on physical properties is shown in Figure 6.4.2.0.

Table 6.4.2.0(a). Material Specifications for HS 188
SpecificationFormCondition
AMS 5608Sheet and plateSolution treated (annealed)
AMS 5772Bar and forgingSolution treated (annealed)
6.4.2.1Solution-Treated Condition

Elevated-temperature properties are presented in Figures 6.4.2.1.1(a) and (b), 6.4.2.1.2, 6.4.2.1.4(a) through (c), and 6.4.2.1.5. Typical tensile stress-strain curves at room temperature are presented in Figure 6.4.2.1.6(a). Typical compressive stress-strain and tangent-modulus curves at room and elevated temperatures are presented in Figure 6.4.2.1.6(b). Strain control fatigue data for bar are presented in Figures 6.4.2.1.8(a) through (d).

Table 6.4.2.0(b). Design Mechanical and Physical Properties of HS 188 Sheet
SpecificationAMS 5608
FormSheet
ConditionSolution Treated
Thickness, in.<0.0200.020-0.187
BasisSS
Mechanical Properties:
Ftu, ksi:
L125125
LT125125
Fty, ksi:
L5757
LT5555
Fcy, ksi:
L······
LT5555
Fsu, ksi111111
Fbru, ksi:
(e/D = 1.5)······
(e/D = 2.0)······
Fbry, ksi:
(e/D = 1.5)······
(e/D = 2.0)······
e, percent:
LT4045
E, 103 ksi33.6
Ec, 103 ksi33.6
G, 103 ksi12.8
μ0.31
Physical Properties:
ω, lb/in.30.324
C, K, and αSee Figure 6.4.2.0
Figure 6.4.2.0Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.2.0. Effect of temperature on the physical properties of HS 188.

Figure 6.4.2.1.1(a)Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.2.1.1(a). Effect of temperature on tensile ultimate strength (Ftu) of HS 188 sheet.

Figure 6.4.2.1.1(b)Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.2.1.1(b). Effect of temperature on tensile yield strength (Fty) of HS 188 sheet.

Figure 6.4.2.1.2Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.2.1.2. Effect of temperature on compressive yield strength (Fcy) of HS 188 sheet.

Figure 6.4.2.1.4(a)Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.2.1.4(a). Effect of temperature on dynamic moduli (E and Ec) of HS 188.

Figure 6.4.2.1.4(b)Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.2.1.4(b). Effect of temperature on dynamic shear modulus (G) for HS 188.

Figure 6.4.2.1.4(c)Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.2.1.4(c). Effect of temperature on Poisson’s ratio (μ) for HS 188.

Figure 6.4.2.1.5Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.2.1.5. Effect of temperature on elongation (e) of HS 188 sheet.

Figure 6.4.2.1.6(a)Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.2.1.6(a). Typical tensile stress-strain curves for HS 188 sheet at room temperature.

Figure 6.4.2.1.6(b)Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.2.1.6(b). Typical compressive stress-strain and compressive tangent- modulus curves for HS 188 sheet at various temperatures.

Figure 6.4.2.1.8(a)Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.2.1.8(a). Best-fit ε/N curve, cyclic stress-strain curve, and mean stress relaxation curve for HS 188 bar, longitudinal orientation at 800°F.

Correlative Information for Figure 6.4.2.1.8(a)

Product Form/Thickness: Bar, 0.5 inch thick diameter

Thermal Mechanical Processing History:
Solution annealed (AMS 5772)

Properties: TUS 102* ksi, TYS 55* ksi, 75°F
E 29,766 ksi, 800°F

Stress-Strain Equations:
Cyclic (Companion Specimens)
Proportional Limit = 60 ksi
(Δσ/2) = 109 (Δεp/2)0.06
Mean Stress Relaxation
Inadequate data at low strain range values

Specimen Details: Uniform gage test section
0.250 inch diameter

Reference: 3.8.1.1.8

* Minimum values from AMS 5772.

Test Parameters:
Strain Rate/Frequency – 20 cpm
Wave Form – Triangular
Temperature – 800°F
Atmosphere – Air

No. of Heats/Lots: 2

Equivalent Strain Equation:
Log Nf = 1.678 − 0.905 log (Δε − 0.00572)
Std. Error of Est., Log (Life) = 0.00176 (1/εeq)
Standard Deviation, Log (Life) = 0.65
R2 = 82%

Sample Size: 18

[Caution: The equivalent strain model may provide unrealistic life predictions for strain ratios and ranges beyond those represented above.]

Figure 6.4.2.1.8(b)Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.2.1.8(b). Best-fit ε/N curve and cyclic stress-strain curve for HS 188 bar, longitudinal orientation at 1200°F.

Correlative Information for Figure 6.4.2.1.8(b)

Product Form/Thickness: Bar, 1.5 inch thick

Thermal Mechanical Processing History:
Solution annealed (AMS 5772)

Properties: TUS 120* ksi, TYS 55* ksi, 75°F
E 20,050 ksi, 1200°F

Stress-Strain Equations:
Cyclic (Companion Specimens)
Proportional Limit = 45 ksi
(Δσ/2) = 293 (Δεp/2)0.22

Specimen Details: Uniform gage test section
0.250 inch diameter

Reference: 3.8.1.1.8

* Minimum values from AMS 5772.

Test Parameters:
Strain Rate/Frequency – 20 cpm
Wave Form – Triangular
Temperature – 1200°F
Atmosphere – Air

No. of Heats/Lots: 1

Equivalent Strain Equation:
Log Nf = 1.073 − 0.925 log (Δε − 0.00622)
Std. Error of Est., Log (Life) = 0.00134 (1/εeq)
Standard Deviation, Log(Life) = 0.61
R2 = 91%

Sample Size: 14

[Caution: The equivalent strain model may provide unrealistic life predictions for strain ratios and ranges beyond those represented above.]

Figure 6.4.2.1.8(c)Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.2.1.8(c). Best-fit ε/N curve and cyclic stress-strain curve for HS 188 bar, longitudinal orientation at 1600°F.

Correlative Information for Figure 6.4.2.1.8(c)

Product Form/Thickness: Bar, 1.5 inch thick

Thermal Mechanical Processing History:
Solution treated, water quenched (AMS 5772)

Properties: TUS 120* ksi, TYS 55* ksi, 75°F
E 22,406 ksi, 1600°F

Stress-Strain Equations:
Cyclic (Companion Specimens)
Proportional Limit = 36 ksi
(Δσ/2) = 81.6 (Δεp/2)0.094

Specimen Details: Uniform gage test section
0.250 inch diameter

Reference: 3.8.1.1.8

* Minimum values from AMS 5772.

Test Parameters:
Strain Rate/Frequency – 20 cpm
Wave Form – Triangular
Temperature – 1600°F
Atmosphere – Air

No. of Heats/Lots: 1

Equivalent Strain Equation:
Log Nf = 0.011 − 1.343 log (Δε − 0.00283)
Std. Error of Estimate, Log (Life) = 0.116
Standard Deviation, Log(Life) = 0.582
R2 = 96%

Sample Size: 16

[Caution: The equivalent strain model may provide unrealistic life predictions for strain ratios and ranges beyond those represented above.]

Figure 6.4.2.1.8(d)Not digitized in this pass.

Figure 6.4.2.1.8(d). Best-fit ε/N curve and cyclic stress-strain curve for HS 188 bar, longitudinal orientation at 1800°F.

Correlative Information for Figure 6.4.2.1.8(d)

Product Form/Thickness: Bar, 1.5 inch thick

Thermal Mechanical Processing History:
Solution treated, water quenched (AMS 5772)

Properties: TUS 120* ksi, TYS 55* ksi, 75°F
E 20,353 ksi, 1800°F

Stress-Strain Equations:
Cyclic (Companion Specimens)
Proportional Limit = 23 ksi
(Δσ/2) = 66.3 (Δεp/2)0.12

Specimen Details: Uniform gage test section
0.250 inch diameter

Reference: 3.8.1.1.8

* Minimum values from AMS 5772.

Test Parameters:
Strain Rate/Frequency – 20 cpm
Wave Form – Triangular
Temperature – 1800°F
Atmosphere – Air

No. of Heats/Lots: 1

Equivalent Strain Equation:
Log Nf = 0.047 − 1.317 log (Δε − 0.00239)
Std. Error of Estimate, Log (Life) = 0.0126
Standard Deviation, Log(Life) = 0.063
R2 = 96%

Sample Size: 15

[Caution: The equivalent strain model may provide unrealistic life predictions for strain ratios and ranges beyond those represented above.]

Cite This Work