NSWC-11 Belt & Chain Drive Reliability Model

V-belts, synchronous (timing) belts and chains are the three common ways to carry power between shafts that are far apart. A V-belt grips by friction and slips on overload, which protects the machine. A timing belt and a chain engage positively, so they do not slip, but they need close alignment and, for chains, regular lubrication.

This tool follows Chapter 21 of the Naval Surface Warfare Center Handbook of Reliability Prediction Procedures for Mechanical Equipment (NSWC-11). For a belt drive it starts from a base rate of 40 failures per million hours. It multiplies that by factors for load, temperature, pulley size, belt type, service and shock. Then it adds the failure rate of the pulleys. For a chain drive the base rate is 15, with factors for service, chain speed, temperature, lubrication and sprocket size, plus the sprockets.

The result is a failure rate per million hours, with FIT and MTBF for a FMECA. Every step of the working is under “Show detailed calculation steps”.

Small pitch belts such as MXL, XL and L are outside the model. They are chosen for positioning, not power, and they run on pulleys below the 2.5 to 8.5 in range of the pulley size factor. Use the belt maker’s life rating for those.
NSWC-11 Chapter 21 Failure Rate Calculator
Belt & Chain Drive Reliability (NSWC-11 Eq. 21-7 / 21-11)
What are you analysing?
A belt drive is rated by its load ratio and pulleys. A chain drive is rated by its speed and sprockets.
Belt Drive
Power the belt actually carries.
The belt manufacturer’s rating (or the prime mover’s). Only the ratio is used.
Table 21-2 lists V-belt sections only. The belt type also sets the pulley type.
Gives the belt speed and working tension below. Set to 0 to skip.
Standard belts run from −20 to 140 °F. Include heat from slip and poor ventilation, not just ambient.
Belt Service & Shock
Used in both Table 21-3 and Table 21-4.
Mission (optional)
8,760 h is one year of continuous operation. Leave blank to skip.
Failure Rate & Reliability Metrics
Predicted Failure Rate, λ (failures / 106 h) iBelt: λBD = λBD,B × CBL × Ct × CPD × CBT × CBV × CSV + λP. Chain: λCD = λCD,B × CCV × CCS × CCT × CCI × CST + λS. The pulley or sprocket rate is added, not multiplied.
–
Failure Rate (FIT) iFailures In Time = failures per 109 hours. The same number as failures per million hours, multiplied by 1000.
–
MTBF (hours) iMean time between failures = 106 / λ. It assumes a constant failure rate. Belts and chains wear out, so use it to compare designs and to feed a FMECA.
–
MTBF (years) iMTBF in hours divided by 24 × 365.25.
–
Expected Failures over the Mission iλ × mission hours / 106. The expected count of failures for one unit, so a value above 1 means one failure is more likely than not.
–
Survival Probability over the Mission iR(t) = e−λt, the chance one unit survives the mission with no failure, assuming a constant failure rate.
–
Intermediates
–
–
–
–
–
Multiplying Factors
SymbolMeaningValue
Show detailed calculation steps
How the Model Works

Both models have the same shape. Each takes a base failure rate for the belt or chain and adjusts it for how hard and how hot it works. Each then adds a fixed failure rate for the pulleys or sprockets. The factors multiply the belt or chain rate only. The pulley or sprocket rate is added afterward.

1. Belt drive

\[ \lambda_{BD} = \lambda_{BD,B}\cdot C_{BL}\cdot C_t\cdot C_{PD}\cdot C_{BT}\cdot C_{BV}\cdot C_{SV} + \lambda_P \qquad\text{(Eq. 21-7)} \]
SymbolMeaning
λBD,BBase failure rate of the belt, 40 failures per million hours
CBLBelt loading, the ratio of actual to rated horsepower (Figure 21.6)
CtBelt operating temperature (Figure 21.7)
CPDDriven pulley diameter (Figure 21.8)
CBTBelt type (Table 21-2)
CBVOperating service (Table 21-3)
CSVShock environment (Table 21-4)
λPPulleys: 0.8 per million hours for flat pulleys, 1.5 for grooved

2. Chain drive

\[ \lambda_{CD} = \lambda_{CD,B}\cdot C_{CV}\cdot C_{CS}\cdot C_{CT}\cdot C_{CI}\cdot C_{ST} + \lambda_S \qquad\text{(Eq. 21-11)} \]
SymbolMeaning
λCD,BBase failure rate of the chain, 15 failures per million hours
CCVOperating service (Table 21-7)
CCSChain speed (Table 21-8)
CCTChain operating temperature (Table 21-9)
CCILubrication method (Table 21-10)
CSTSprocket design, 19 / ST (Figure 21.16)
λSDriver and driven sprockets, 0.8 failures per million hours

3. Tension and speed (information)

The handbook relates belt and chain life to tension, but its failure-rate equations use the ratios above, not the tensions themselves. The page shows the speeds and tensions for reference. Belt speed is V = πDN/12 (Eq. 21-1) and working tension is TW = 33,000 hp/V (Eq. 21-3). Chain speed is S = PNn/12 (Eq. 21-8) and chain tension is T = 33,000 hp/S. A belt also carries bending tension TB = CB/d (Eq. 21-4) and centrifugal tension TC = MV2 (Eq. 21-5). Its peak tension is TPEAK = TT + TB + TC (Eq. 21-6). The peak is what ties to belt life. Those need belt-specific constants (CB and M) that the handbook does not tabulate, so they are not computed here.

Which belts the model covers

The belt model is for power transmission V-belts. Table 21-2 gives a belt type factor only for the classical sections Y, Z, A, B, C and D and the narrow wedge sections SPZ, SPA, SPB and SPC. All of these run on grooved pulleys, so the calculator sets the pulley type for you.

The handbook describes flat belts and timing belts, but it gives no belt type factor for them. You can still pick them and enter your own CBT. A flat belt uses the flat pulley rate, and a timing belt uses the grooved rate. Treat those results as rough.

Small timing belts such as MXL, XL and L are outside the model. They are chosen for positioning, not power, and they run on pulleys smaller than the 2.5 to 8.5 in range of the pulley size factor. For those, use the belt maker’s life rating.

4. Step by step

  1. Pick belt or chain.
  2. Enter the load, speed, temperature and sizes. Pick the service and shock (or lubrication) conditions from the handbook tables.
  3. The calculator multiplies the base rate by each factor, then adds the pulley or sprocket rate.
  4. Convert to FIT and MTBF, and, with a mission time, to expected failures and survival probability.
Read the result with care. Belt life depends heavily on installation tension and alignment. Chain life depends on lubrication and wear elongation. A handful of factors cannot fully capture any of these. The handbook quotes about 20,000 to 25,000 h for a well-applied V-drive and at least 12,000 h for a timing belt. Use those lives as a sanity check on the MTBF the calculator gives.
Factor Reference Guide
NSWC-11 Chapter 21: Belt and Chain Drives
CBL

Belt Load Factor: CBL

Equation: NSWC-11 Figure 21.6
Eq. CBL \[ C_{BL} = 0.3 + \left(\frac{hp_O/hp_D}{1.1}\right)^{4.2} \]

The belt has to be tight enough not to slip. The harder it works relative to its rating, the faster it wears. hpO is the actual load and hpD is the design or rated load. Their ratio is how loaded the belt is. The factor is about 1.0 at the rated load, falls to 0.45 at 70 % and climbs steeply, to 12.6 at twice the rating.

The manufacturer normally publishes the belt’s horsepower rating. If you only have a torque rating, convert it with hp = TW·V / 33,000 (Eq. 21-3), or use the prime mover’s rating.

The printed curve covers a ratio of 0.7 to 2.0. The calculator warns outside that.
CBL vs load ratio (NSWC-11 Fig. 21.6)
Ct

Belt Temperature Factor: Ct

Equation: NSWC-11 Figure 21.7
Eq. Ct \[ C_t = \frac{1}{2^{t}},\qquad t = \begin{cases} 0 & -20 \le T_O \le 40\,^\circ\text{F}\\[4pt] \dfrac{40 - T_O}{55} & T_O > 40\,^\circ\text{F} \end{cases} \]

Above 40 °F, t is negative, so the factor is 2 raised to a positive power. The failure rate doubles for every 55 °F rise. It is about 2.1 at 100 °F and 7.5 at 200 °F. Heat hardens the belt compound, raises its stiffness and cuts its elongation. Cracks then start in the cushion stock, and the belt eventually cannot carry its cords.

Standard belts are designed for −20 to 140 °F, and published ratings are often at 85 °F. Use the temperature the belt really sees, including heat from slip, worn grooves, tight bends and poor ventilation. Very low temperatures also hurt, since compounds can reach their glass transition and fail suddenly. The model does not penalize cold below 40 °F, so the handbook’s cold-weather warning is not captured by this factor.

Ct vs operating temperature (NSWC-11 Fig. 21.7)
CPD

Pulley Diameter Factor: CPD

Equation: NSWC-11 Figure 21.8
Eq. CPD \[ C_{PD} = 2\left(\frac{4.5}{PD}\right)^{2} \]

A belt bends more sharply around a small pulley, which raises the bending tension and the fatigue damage on each pass. PD is the driven pulley diameter in inches. The factor is 2.0 at 4.5 in, rises to 6.5 at 2.5 in and falls to 0.56 at 8.5 in. The printed plot covers 2.5 to 8.5 in.

CPD vs driven pulley diameter (NSWC-11 Fig. 21.8)
T 21-2 to 21-4

Belt Type, Service & Shock Factors

Table 21-2: Belt type, CBT
Belt typeCBT
SPZ0.8
SPA0.48
SPB0.33
SPC0.18
Y9.09
Z4.16
A0.93
B0.54
C0.30
D0.14
SP types are narrow (wedge) V-belts. Y to D are classical V-belt sections. The factor falls as the belt section gets bigger, because a bigger belt carries more power.
Table 21-4: Shock environment, CSV
Driven machineryLow or normal torqueHigh or non-uniform torque
No shock1.11.2
Light shock1.21.3
Medium shock1.31.5
Heavy shock1.41.7
Table 21-3: Operating service, CBV (handbook reference 39)
Typical loadsLow or normal torqueHigh or non-uniform torque
Interm.NormalContin.Interm.NormalContin.
Blowers, small fans, centrifugal pumps, compressors1.01.11.21.11.21.3
Generators, machine tools, rotary pumps1.11.21.31.21.31.4
Low or normal torque: small AC motors, shunt wound DC motors, small engines. High or non-uniform torque: single phase AC motors, series wound DC motors, large internal combustion engines.

The same “source of power” choice feeds both tables. These are the driver-pulley factors from Shigley and Mischke, and they raise the failure rate as the duty gets harder.

λP

Pulley & Sprocket Failure Rates

Added, not multiplied

The pulleys and sprockets have their own failure rates, which the handbook adds to the belt or chain term. A belt drive adds 0.8 failures per million hours for flat pulleys or 1.5 for grooved pulleys. A chain drive adds 0.8 failures per million hours for its driver and driven sprockets.

Because these terms are fixed, they set a floor under the failure rate. A drive with a very low belt or chain term still fails at least that often. In the worked examples the pulleys are about 2 % of the belt result and the sprockets about 3 % of the chain result.

T 21-7

Chain Operating Service: CCV

Table 21-7

The factor depends on how smooth the driver is and how much impact the driven load has. The harder the duty, the higher the factor.

Type of driven loadSmooth running (electric motors, turbines)Slight shock (electric motors with frequent starts, IC engine with hydraulic coupling)Moderate shocks (IC engines with mechanical coupling)
Smooth (conveyers with small load fluctuations, centrifugal blowers)1.01.11.3
Some impact (conveyers with some load fluctuations, centrifugal compressors, marine engines)1.41.51.7
Large impact (machines with reverse or large impact loads)1.81.92.1
Multiple strands (Table 21-6)

Take care with catalog horsepower ratings for a chain with more than one strand. The total rating is not the single-strand rating times the number of strands. Use this factor.

Roller chain strands123456
Multiple strand factor1.01.72.53.33.94.6
T 21-8 – 21-10

Chain Speed, Temperature & Lubrication

Table 21-8: Chain speed, CCS
Chain speedCCS
< 50 ft/min1.0
50 – 100 ft/min1.2
> 100 – 160 ft/min1.4
Chain speed S = P·N·n / 12 (Eq. 21-8), in ft/min. Above 160 ft/min the handbook gives no value. The page holds 1.4 and warns.
Table 21-9: Chain temperature, CCT
TemperatureCCT
≤ 170 °C1.0
170 – 200 °C1.5
> 200 – 260 °C2.0
Table 21-10: Lubrication, CCI
Type of lubricationCCI
Manual operation1.5
Drip lubrication1.0
Bath lubrication0.8
Stream lubrication0.7

Proper lubrication cuts wear on every moving surface and cushions the chain from shock. Manual oiling suits slow, intermittent work. An oil bath suits most applications, and recirculating or stream lubrication is used at high speed and power. Chain life depends on adequate lubrication more than on anything else the handbook lists.

When a chain has stretched about 3 % it normally needs replacing, because its case-hardened surfaces are gone. Wear elongation under 1.5 % for a transmission chain, or 2 % for a conveyor chain, carries almost no fatigue risk.

CST

Sprocket Design Factor: CST

Equation: NSWC-11 Figure 21.16
Eq. CST \[ C_{ST} = \frac{19}{ST},\qquad ST = \text{teeth on the smaller sprocket} \]

A chain can only bend at its pitch points, so a sprocket with few teeth makes the chain articulate sharply and vibrate more. More teeth give a smoother engagement. The factor is 1.0 at 19 teeth, 1.27 at 15 and 0.76 at 25. The printed plot covers 15 to 25 teeth.

CST vs sprocket teeth (NSWC-11 Fig. 21.16)
T 21-1

Belt Drive Failure Modes

The most common belt failure is a broken belt caused by improper tensioning. There is a tension for optimum life: above it fatigue shortens life, and below it slip does.

Failure modeFailure causeFailure effect
Improper operating tensionInstallation errorBelt failure
Pulley/sheave misalignmentInstallation errorSidewall cracking and belt failure
Worn pulley/sheaveIncorrect tensionBelt slippage and rapid wear rate
Temperature extremeBelt slippage, operating environmentBelt hardening and reduced life
Chemical contaminationOperating environmentBelt wear and eventual failure
Foreign objects in the belt drive assemblyOperating environmentBelt wear and eventual failure
Belt slipInsufficient tensionExcessive heat and wear generated with reduced belt life
Belt fatigueExcessive tensionBroken belt
Worn belt and pulley/sheaveLarge starting and stopping forces greater than 10% above operating conditionsPremature belt failure
Normal wear rateNormal repetitive stressingEventual belt failure
Rapid belt deteriorationHeat build-up due to inadequate ventilationVariation in drive ratio and reduced belt life
Improper belt drive operationLoose pulley/sheave on shaftSidewall cracking and belt failure
Handbook Table 21-1. V-belt drives are limited to about ½° of misalignment and synchronous belts to about ¼°.
T 21-5

Chain Drive Failure Modes

A chain can fail in four ways. It can break in tension. It can fail in tensile fatigue, where cracks grow in the link plates below the yield load. It can wear until it no longer fits the sprockets. Or the pin and bushing can gall at high speed and load. Wear elongation is the key factor that makes a chain jump sprocket teeth.

Failure modeFailure causeFailure effect
Turned/galled pinsInadequate lubricationDamaged chain
Enlarged holesOverloadDamaged chain
Broken pins and/or link platesExtreme overloadDamaged chain and sprockets
Worn link plate contoursChain rubbing on chain guideDamaged chain
Cracked link platesExcessive loading; corrosive environmentChain fatigue failure; stress corrosion failure
Broken, cracked or deformed rollersExcessive speed, chain riding too high on sprocket teethDamaged chain
Chain climbs sprocket teethExcessive chain slack; overloadChain and sprocket wear failure
Foreign objects in the chain drive assemblyOperating environmentChain wear and eventual failure
Excessive noiseChain interference; loose casing; excessive chain slack; inadequate lubricationEventual chain damage
Bushing/roller fatigueChain loadingChain wear and eventual failure
Chain elongationLink-pin joint wearChain begins to skip teeth followed by complete failure
Tensile fatigue loadingSideplate loadingSudden catastrophic chain failure
Handbook Table 21-5.
Worked Example

Belt drive. A B-section V-belt on grooved pulleys carries 8 hp against a 10 hp rating (a load ratio of 0.8). The driven pulley is 6 in in diameter and turns at 1,750 rpm, and the belt runs at 120 °F. The source of power is a single-phase motor (high or non-uniform torque), driving a generator or machine tool in normal service with light shock. These are the calculator’s default inputs.

Step-by-step (belt)
  • CBL = 0.3 + (0.8/1.1)4.2 = 0.5625
  • Ct = 2(120−40)/55 = 2.7407
  • CPD = 2 × (4.5/6)2 = 1.125
  • CBT = 0.54 (B section), CBV = 1.3 (generators and machine tools, high torque, normal service), CSV = 1.3 (light shock, high torque)

λBD = 40 × 0.5625 × 2.7407 × 1.125 × 0.54 × 1.3 × 1.3 + 1.5 = 63.31 + 1.5 ≈ 64.8 failures / 106 h, an MTBF of 15,430 h. That is a little under the 20,000 to 25,000 h the handbook quotes for a well-applied V-drive. Over a year (8,760 h) the expected failure count is 0.57 and the survival probability is 56.7 %. For information, the belt speed is 2,749 ft/min and the working tension is 96 lb. The temperature factor of 2.74 is the largest single contributor, so better ventilation would help most.

Chain drive. Switch to chain. A roller chain of 3/4 in pitch runs on a 17-tooth smaller sprocket at 150 rpm and carries 5 hp. A smooth electric motor drives a conveyer with some load fluctuation. The chain runs at 100 °C in an oil bath.

  • S = 0.75 × 17 × 150 / 12 = 159.4 ft/min, so CCS = 1.4 (the last row of Table 21-8)
  • CCV = 1.4 (smooth driver, some impact), CCT = 1.0 (100 °C), CCI = 0.8 (bath)
  • CST = 19/17 = 1.1176

λCD = 15 × 1.4 × 1.4 × 1.0 × 0.8 × 1.1176 + 0.8 = 26.29 + 0.8 ≈ 27.1 failures / 106 h, an MTBF of 36,918 h. The chain tension is 33,000 × 5 / 159.4 = 1,035 lb.

Important Notices
  • Not an official DoD document. NSWC-11 is the product of a Naval Surface Warfare Center research program, approved for public release. The handbook cautions that limited funding prevented full validation of every prediction equation. It should not be treated as an official Department of Defense standard.
  • No Navy affiliation or endorsement. The Naval Surface Warfare Center, Carderock Division and the U.S. Navy have not participated in the development of this calculator and do not approve or endorse it.
  • Use with the full procedure. NSWC-11 warns against extracting equations without regard to application procedures and parameter limits. Results are a design screening tool, not a substitute for the manufacturer’s rating, testing, or the judgment of a qualified engineer.
  • Drive only. The rate covers the belt or chain and its pulleys or sprockets. The bearings and shafts that carry them have their own rates, so use the bearing and shaft calculators for those.
  • Installation matters. Belt tension and alignment strongly affect life. So do chain lubrication and elongation. They enter the model only through the service and load factors. Good installation and maintenance are assumed.
  • Limits of the tables. The chain speed table stops at 160 ft/min and the chain temperature table at 260 °C. Beyond them the page holds the last value and warns. The belt factors are plotted over limited ranges, which the page also checks.
  • Constant failure rate. An MTBF assumes a constant failure rate. Belts and chains wear out, so treat the estimate as a rough guide over long missions.

Cite This Work